Way back in the summer of 1983, my friend Bob Burr decided to expand our local Holmes club newsletter to an eight page format from one double-sided legal sheet. Plugs & Dottles, as the monthly publication of the Hansoms of John Clayton was called, was overflowing the old format, but not quite big enough for the new, so Bob asked the good Carter and myself to help him by writing a monthly column for the center of the newsletter. Thus started an avocation of writing about Sherlock Holmes and Sherlockiana that has continued to this day, transforming from newsletter column to internet blogging.
And with this hobby of ours, I have never run out of material. I could write about Sherlockiana every day, if I put myself to the task. There are so many parts and pieces to the lore that has grown up around Sherlock Holmes since 1887 that we can't even document them all any more. Ron B. DeWaal tried, back before the internet exploded, and once the nineties came, that task went from Herculean to impossible. And just to simply define "Sherlockiana" is quite the puzzle, which is what I like to write about, again and again . . . sometimes getting myself in a wee bit of trouble.
Why was it such a boys club back in the day? Can Doyleans and Game-players coexist in the same space? How can people be fans of an actor they never saw perform, before rare footage of him was finally found? What was the deal with old fans trying to barricade the hobby against a delightfully huge influx of new fans from a certain BBC series? Has plutocracy crept into the hobby, or was it there all along?
Sherlockiana is a fascinating spectrum of people from all walks of life coming at a single fictional hero and his entourage from so many different perspectives. Part of the joy of our hobby is the opportunity to meet, mingle, and really get to know folks our normal work/life balance would never bring us in contact with. And every one of those folks has a different opinion of what makes this hobby great. We may align along this line or that, but do we every match up perfectly? Oh, no . . .
Figuring out Sherlockiana is part of the fun when your enthusiasm for Holmes finally takes you past those original sixty stories and the pastiches that probably got you to them, be those pastiches film, television, or novels. You have to decide which path you're going to follow, even if you have a trusty guide offering you their experience in this land of fans. And that part never ends.
Even for those of us who've been doing this for decades upon decades, following trail after trail, down rabbit holes, cross the pond, wandering aimlessly at times just wondering at what we discover . . . there are always times when you have to stand still for a second and just go, "Where to next?" Video gamers love an open world game, and like them, we have a wide open world in Sherlockiana's landscape. You can tread the well-worn paths to the more crowded centers of things, or you can go roaming the places few decide to go.
Writing is a good practice for meditating upon a thing, following your own thoughts to a conclusion, as you let the words put them in order. It's good to remember that in a day when the more foolish think offloading anything that challenges them to a software brain is going to make them appear better than they are without actually being better. And that, my friends, is one more Sherlockian topic for us to figure out.
Figuring out Sherlockiana is half the fun. Don't ever let that fun slip away from you.





