Sunday, November 15, 2026

Figuring Out Sherlockiana

 Way back in the summer of 1983, my friend Bob Burr decided to expand our local Holmes club newsletter to an eight page format from one double-sided legal sheet. Plugs & Dottles, as the monthly publication of the Hansoms of John Clayton was called, was overflowing the old format, but not quite big enough for the new, so Bob asked the good Carter and myself to help him by writing a monthly column for the center of the newsletter. Thus started an avocation of writing about Sherlock Holmes and Sherlockiana that has continued to this day, transforming from newsletter column to internet blogging.

And with this hobby of ours, I have never run out of material. I could write about Sherlockiana every day, if I put myself to the task. There are so many parts and pieces to the lore that has grown up around Sherlock Holmes since 1887 that we can't even document them all any more. Ron B. DeWaal tried, back before the internet exploded, and once the nineties came, that task went from Herculean to impossible. And just to simply define "Sherlockiana" is quite the puzzle, which is what I like to write about, again and again . . . sometimes getting myself in a wee bit of trouble.

Why was it such a boys club back in the day? Can Doyleans and Game-players coexist in the same space? How can people be fans of an actor they never saw perform, before rare footage of him was finally found? What was the deal with old fans trying to barricade the hobby against a delightfully huge influx of new fans from a certain BBC series? Has plutocracy crept into the hobby, or was it there all along?

Sherlockiana is a fascinating spectrum of people from all walks of life coming at a single fictional hero and his entourage from so many different perspectives. Part of the joy of our hobby is the opportunity to meet, mingle, and really get to know folks our normal work/life balance would never bring us in contact with. And every one of those folks has a different opinion of what makes this hobby great. We may align along this line or that, but do we every match up perfectly? Oh, no . . .

Figuring out Sherlockiana is part of the fun when your enthusiasm for Holmes finally takes you past those original sixty stories and the pastiches that probably got you to them, be those pastiches film, television, or novels.  You have to decide which path you're going to follow, even if you have a trusty guide offering you their experience in this land of fans. And that part never ends.

Even for those of us who've been doing this for decades upon decades, following trail after trail, down rabbit holes, cross the pond, wandering aimlessly at times just wondering at what we discover . . . there are always times when you have to stand still for a second and just go, "Where to next?" Video gamers love an open world game, and like them, we have a wide open world in Sherlockiana's landscape. You can tread the well-worn paths to the more crowded centers of things, or you can go roaming the places few decide to go.

Writing is a good practice for meditating upon a thing, following your own thoughts to a conclusion, as you let the words put them in order. It's good to remember that in a day when the more foolish think offloading anything that challenges them to a software brain is going to make them appear better than they are without actually being better. And that, my friends, is one more Sherlockian topic for us to figure out.

Figuring out Sherlockiana is half the fun. Don't ever let that fun slip away from you.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

A Regular Sherlockian Night in Indianapolis

 Sherlockian travels can take all sorts of forms. The big weekends, the special events, and even just going to see what regular Sherlockian life is like in a given city. As my wife and I were looking for somewhere to go for the weekend for a quiet celebration of something I won't ballyhoo here, and the Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis were having a meeting a few hours down the road, we chose Indy as our destination of choice, and had dinner with the Clients Saturday night.

The Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis like their dinner meetings, something like eight times a year. In my various visits to that city, I've gotten to see the insides of at least five different country clubs, as those tend to be their venue of choice lately (though I do remember one fabulous Greek restaurant years in the past, and a German one as well). Saturday's meeting had about forty people show up at the Country Club of Indianapolis, a fine venue with a lovely large bar in the banquet room.

The story for the night was "The Adventure of the Naval Treaty," and each table had a covered dish in the center, which we were eventually told to uncover to discover our own naval treaty as disguised in the story, all written in French, just like in the story. The difference, however, was that our treaty was not about naval defense but about what order we'd get to go to the dinner buffet in. Our table got "cinq" which was basically French for "last," in this case. No worries there, though, as we had an excellent table company with the Aults from Valparaiso, and Kelly Hodges from Kokomo. (The Indiana Kokomo, not the Beach Boys one.)

One thing you notice immediately about the Illustrious Clients en masse is their club tie, worn as a normal necktie with a jacket by some, but creatively redesigned for a less masculine piece of apparel by others. The Clients fly their colours, and it's quite a thing to see. As I said, they like a banquet meeting, and their normal banquet meetings look like the annual dinner banquet from the heyday of Peoria's Hansoms of John Clayton, so their "normal" is a nice evening for myself and the good Carter.

While we ate, they had their toasts -- based on the story of the evening, which was nice -- and we rolled through toasts to Percy Phelps by Alan Schweitzer, Annie Harrison by Ann Lewis, Dr. Watson by Shelly Gage, Mrs. Hudson by Regina Stinson (via Zoom) annnnd Joseph Harrison by Steve Doyle. If you thought that last one sounds like a dangerous combination, you would be right, as Steve came up with a clever defense of Percy Phelps's brother-in-law that haunted later discussions that evening.

The Clients have an interesting show and tell segment, which other scions have borrowed to some success, in which unique items of Sherlockian interest get explained and shown. I'd try to explain them here but probably fail to do them justice. Sherlock Holmes has inspired such an incredible variety of artifacts that it boggles the imagination sometimes.

A quiz on "Naval Treaty" had been put on the tables early on, and quizmistress Kira Settingsgaard provided the answers. Out of twenty-four possible point, I got fourteen, but a good share of the Clients seemed better prepared and did much better. The quiz was followed by a story discussion led by Mark Walters, going through several key points of the tale, and trying to discourage negative comments about Percy Phelps, the client and victim of the tale, which might have been inspired by a certain Joseph Harrison toast earlier. Personally, I came away from the evening with much less respect for Percy Phelps than I had begun with.

I mean, think about it, this guy was entrusted with a highly, highly, HIGHLY secret government treaty, loses it, then after a curiously convenient bout of "brain fever," thinks, "Oh, I'll write a boy I knew at school who is publishing stories in The Strand Magazine to get his famous friend to find the TOP SECRET document."  Sure, Percy. Sure.

The evening closed with Kelly Hodges, a newly minted Client and recent Irene Adler on the Kokomo stage, reading Vincent Starrett's poem 221B, which is the classic way to finish any Sherlockian evening. 

All in all, the Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis do a well organized, very nice meeting, and have for quite a long time. You don't have to wait for a special event to have a nice evening there. But as bad evenings, afternoons, mornings, or what have you are rare amongst all of the Sherlockian societies I've ever visited, so I'd encourage looking for convenient opportunities down the road from wherever you are. Eventually you have to drive home, but you'll get a lot to think about on the way and probably come away inspired for future Sherlockian adventures.

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Is Yours A Library or Lumber-Room?

 “I say now, as I said then, that a man should keep his little brain-attic stocked with all the furniture that he is likely to use, and the rest he can put away in the lumber-room of his library, where he can get it if he wants it."

-- Sherlock Holmes, "The Adventure of the Five Orange Pips"

Last week, I saw a comment on a social post, from one Sherlockian to another, suggesting that books should be shared and not hoarded. "Hoarded" seemed like a strong word for the collecting impulse that has run through Sherlockians like a virus since our early days, but I understood the point. Eventually one reaches an age when they start to wonder how their books will live on past their owner, which can cause one to wonder "Why DO I have all these books?"

When I was younger, non-Sherlockian, non-reader visitors would often ask, "Have you read all those books?" It seemed like such a silly question. Why would I own books that I hadn't read? Over time, however, as the Sherlockian collecting impulse wore away at me, I started to own a lot of books I hadn't read. Reference books, of course, which aren't meant to be read cover-to-cover. Biographies, which might have been meant to be read cover-to-cover, but often just serve as reference books after the fourth or fifth book on the same man's life. And those alternate copies of the same sixty stories -- old pirate editions, editions with unique illustrations, etc.

Enjoyable new novels of Sherlock Holmes, both pastiches and those featuring Holmes-based characters, remain on the shelves as reminders and tributes to the authors who wrote them. The dull, pedestrian works tend to get re-homed at one Sherlockian event or another. As the decades have passed, a lot of Sherlock Holmes books have left my library when they proved less than memorable, for reasons good OR bad. And at this point, even some quality works have left the shelves as the honest realization comes that I'm never going to refer to the particular subject at the heart of the book in my remaining years. I hate to say which, as I especially don't want to upset fans of a particular actor since my home went particular-actor-free a little while back. But that move also delighted one particular fan of that particular actor in the largess they received as the books left my house.

And that's the point that I think the "hoarding" comment was intended to make. When we're young we dream of shelves and shelves of books filling our house. But as lovely as a home library can be, it can also turn into a graveyard of books that won't see another reader until an estate sale. At some point, setting a few free to find new owners to love them is not a bad thing.

When Sherlock Holmes said that notable thing about brain-attics and lumber-room libraries, he was talking about internally held facts, but it also can apply to our external libraries. A person should keep all the books they are likely to use in the future, whether for reference or rereading. But there are also a good many that can be put away in the hands of other Sherlockians, where they can finally get to them if they want them.

There are personal libraries, organized, curated, loved. And then there are lumber rooms where books are just piled and stored as time goes by and we let it all get away from us. I've had both, so I'm not going to shame anyone for letting the Sherlockiana pile up. It happens. But eventually . . . eventually! . . . it's good to take an objective look at the books one owns and decide where their best home might be. Or not. You do you and enjoy whatever that winds up being.

Wednesday, October 21, 2026

The Deerstalker Lady

 In 2026, the age of everything everwhere all of the time via the internet, it is truly hard to wrap one's head around the Sherlockian experience of forty years ago in 1886. The level of hunger for things related to Sherlock Holmes, the barren Holmes and Watson landscape we spent our days in, the simple fact that if ANY book that starred Sherlock Holmes crossed your path you bought it . . . it was a very different time.

On the wall behind my computer screen is a little picture that always reminds me of those days, as it's not something that would probably seem a must-have to a 2026 Sherlockian.


It's simply a lady in hunting garb, with a rifle and a deerstalker cap.

In the 1980s, if a character was wearing a deerstalker, be it Snoopy, Garfield, a Cabbage Patch kid, etc., etc., etc., they were plainly imagining they were Sherlock Holmes and collectors grabbed up whatever form they appeared in. This deerstalker lady, however, was definitely not playing Sherlock Holmes carrying a rifle -- a form of weaponry Holmes never picks up in the original Canon. She's plainly just a woman going hunting.

But in the 1980s, a time when the Baker Street Irregulars did not invite women to their annual New York dinner, this image of a woman in a deerstalker felt like it held an added statement, and when I encountered it in the framing store where I had taken a particular item to get framed, it seemed a must-buy.

Will this simple print have any meaning down the line, when my Sherlockian collection eventually gets dispersed to the winds when I am gone? That will be for whoever's hands it falls into to decide -- we each give these objects meaning as we go through our lives. But for now, the deerstalker lady remains on my wall, reminding me of a time long ago when things were very different.

So, you go, deerstalker lady. Hope you bagged whatever you were hunting for.



Friday, October 9, 2026

In Defense of Will Ferrell's Sherlock Holmes

 Catching up on some television I missed this week, with a changing of the guard between seasons finished and seasons started, and found my way back to The Hawk on Netflix, a comedy about a has-been pro golfer intent on making a comeback. It starred Will Ferrell, playing a typical Will Ferrell character, and brought back to mind his Sherlock Holmes from the movie Holmes & Watson.

A typical Will Ferrell character is a prideful idiot, the sort who thinks he's the best at whatever he does, being it golf, basketball, TV anchoring, Eurovision Song Contest, you name it. And did Sherlock Holmes think he was the best at what he did?

Yes, he did. It's Canon. Score one point for Mr. Ferrell.

And somehow, yes, somehow, those prideful idiots succeed by the end of the movie. And did Sherlock Holmes succeed at the end of a case?

Well, mostly.

And a typical Will Ferrell character has enormous weaknesses. Bad habits, poor social graces . . . oh, wait, doesn't Sherlock Holmes have those same traits?

So why is it that a few Sherlockians so disdain a Will Ferrell Sherlock Holmes whilst celebrating Michael Caine's idiot Holmes in Without A Clue? Why do they decry Ferrell as an American miscasting mistake whilst accepting two movies from Robert Downey Jr., who doesn't even hit the Holmes height requirement like Will Ferrell.

Well, I could say some fans might take their fandom a little too seriously to have some fun with Holmes & Watson. Or I could say some folks have that Saturday Night Live issue, where they bonded with one season's cast in their childhood and won't accept the comic stylings of any other. Or, I could just say, well, it's okay if they don't get it, because sometimes, life just takes you on a sub-optimal path. But all of those would be ad hominum arguments, the last resort of the desperate debater that we see so often in the modern political arenas. And Holmes & Watson doesn't need that. It's got John C. Reilly. It's got Kelly Macdonald. Rebecca Hall. Hugh Laurie. Ralph Fiennes. Lauren Lapkus. Steve Coogan. Rob Brydon. And Queen freakin' Victoria, who they say was played by someone called Pam Ferris, but that sure looked like Queen Victoria to me. That's a cast!

The theme song to Netflix's The Hawk is lyrically brief: "They call him the Hawk. He's a golfer. The greatest golfer in the world."

Can you hear an echo of Sherlock Holmes in those words? I can. But maybe that's because I relate to those characters the same way I've always related to Sherlock Holmes. Prideful, socially inept, but somehow sure it's all going to work out in the end. And maybe just self-aware enough to connect to just being an idiot sometimes. And like the much lauded The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes, which shares a few things with Holmes & Watson, maybe that's what makes it a favorite of mine.

Your mileage may vary, so enjoy whatever movie you're driving for whatever your favorites are. But Holmes & Watson is not a movie to be so easily dismissed.


Saturday, September 26, 2026

Demolishing the Yew Alley

 It's not often that one does Sherlockian yardwork.

But today, after mowing the lawn I decided that a certain corner of the lawn, which had been host to some weeds, needed to be more mower friendly, and generally cleaned up for the next owners to come a few years down the road. Paving stones, border bricks, a pedestal with a sundial, all butting up to a corner of an eight foot wooden fence.

That wooden fence wasn't always there. When we moved into our home, nearly three decades ago, our entire backyard was bordered by a picket fence, meant for keeping little kids and small dogs from running off. It was old and a bit rickety, and when a new neighbor to the north moved in and wanted a more secure metal fence for their dog, we said "Sure, you can replace the fence on your side!" Eventually the same question came from our backyard neighbor for their larger dogs, and a larger fence went in. And finally, the same for our neighbor to the south. "Good fences make good neighbors," as the saying goes.

Yet before all that took place, when we first moved in, a path had been build between our backyard and the house diagonally across from the southwest corner said yard. And that house was owned by my old Sherlockian friend, Bob Burr, who had spent the previous six months of his retired life seeing houses for sale on his morning walks and suggesting we move into his neighborhood. And after several rounds of "No, we want a TWO car garage!" and the like, he did find us one that met all our requirements, catty-cornered to his own property.

I'm not sure who decided their house was Baskerville Hall in the ensuing months, but we got permission from the other neighbors to make a little walk between our yards which we called "the Yew Alley" after the site in The Hound of the Baskervilles. Newsletter columns, proofs of journals, new books picked up for my friend -- all those things and more started using that route for delivery. And since I could look down from an upstairs window to see when Bob was out on his back patio for his evening cocktail, just delivering any news or gossip in person became an easy thing as well via the Yew Alley.

When Bob passed away in 2013, the passage was closed off, yet the landscaping I'd put in that corner remained. The sundial he had so carefully calibrated when I went to put it in. The short path of stones that now went nowhere. And after thirteen years of upkeep worthy of a drunken Hudson of a gardener, the corner slowly became a shadow of its former self, and the time for clean-up had come.

So, raising a glass to the morning's efforts, and that happy past this chore came from, I'm bidding adieu to the last of the Yew Alley today. Glad to have had it while we did.