Sunday, November 15, 2026

Figuring Out Sherlockiana

 Way back in the summer of 1983, my friend Bob Burr decided to expand our local Holmes club newsletter to an eight page format from one double-sided legal sheet. Plugs & Dottles, as the monthly publication of the Hansoms of John Clayton was called, was overflowing the old format, but not quite big enough for the new, so Bob asked the good Carter and myself to help him by writing a monthly column for the center of the newsletter. Thus started an avocation of writing about Sherlock Holmes and Sherlockiana that has continued to this day, transforming from newsletter column to internet blogging.

And with this hobby of ours, I have never run out of material. I could write about Sherlockiana every day, if I put myself to the task. There are so many parts and pieces to the lore that has grown up around Sherlock Holmes since 1887 that we can't even document them all any more. Ron B. DeWaal tried, back before the internet exploded, and once the nineties came, that task went from Herculean to impossible. And just to simply define "Sherlockiana" is quite the puzzle, which is what I like to write about, again and again . . . sometimes getting myself in a wee bit of trouble.

Why was it such a boys club back in the day? Can Doyleans and Game-players coexist in the same space? How can people be fans of an actor they never saw perform, before rare footage of him was finally found? What was the deal with old fans trying to barricade the hobby against a delightfully huge influx of new fans from a certain BBC series? Has plutocracy crept into the hobby, or was it there all along?

Sherlockiana is a fascinating spectrum of people from all walks of life coming at a single fictional hero and his entourage from so many different perspectives. Part of the joy of our hobby is the opportunity to meet, mingle, and really get to know folks our normal work/life balance would never bring us in contact with. And every one of those folks has a different opinion of what makes this hobby great. We may align along this line or that, but do we every match up perfectly? Oh, no . . .

Figuring out Sherlockiana is part of the fun when your enthusiasm for Holmes finally takes you past those original sixty stories and the pastiches that probably got you to them, be those pastiches film, television, or novels.  You have to decide which path you're going to follow, even if you have a trusty guide offering you their experience in this land of fans. And that part never ends.

Even for those of us who've been doing this for decades upon decades, following trail after trail, down rabbit holes, cross the pond, wandering aimlessly at times just wondering at what we discover . . . there are always times when you have to stand still for a second and just go, "Where to next?" Video gamers love an open world game, and like them, we have a wide open world in Sherlockiana's landscape. You can tread the well-worn paths to the more crowded centers of things, or you can go roaming the places few decide to go.

Writing is a good practice for meditating upon a thing, following your own thoughts to a conclusion, as you let the words put them in order. It's good to remember that in a day when the more foolish think offloading anything that challenges them to a software brain is going to make them appear better than they are without actually being better. And that, my friends, is one more Sherlockian topic for us to figure out.

Figuring out Sherlockiana is half the fun. Don't ever let that fun slip away from you.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

A Regular Sherlockian Night in Indianapolis

 Sherlockian travels can take all sorts of forms. The big weekends, the special events, and even just going to see what regular Sherlockian life is like in a given city. As my wife and I were looking for somewhere to go for the weekend for a quiet celebration of something I won't ballyhoo here, and the Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis were having a meeting a few hours down the road, we chose Indy as our destination of choice, and had dinner with the Clients Saturday night.

The Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis like their dinner meetings, something like eight times a year. In my various visits to that city, I've gotten to see the insides of at least five different country clubs, as those tend to be their venue of choice lately (though I do remember one fabulous Greek restaurant years in the past, and a German one as well). Saturday's meeting had about forty people show up at the Country Club of Indianapolis, a fine venue with a lovely large bar in the banquet room.

The story for the night was "The Adventure of the Naval Treaty," and each table had a covered dish in the center, which we were eventually told to uncover to discover our own naval treaty as disguised in the story, all written in French, just like in the story. The difference, however, was that our treaty was not about naval defense but about what order we'd get to go to the dinner buffet in. Our table got "cinq" which was basically French for "last," in this case. No worries there, though, as we had an excellent table company with the Aults from Valparaiso, and Kelly Hodges from Kokomo. (The Indiana Kokomo, not the Beach Boys one.)

One thing you notice immediately about the Illustrious Clients en masse is their club tie, worn as a normal necktie with a jacket by some, but creatively redesigned for a less masculine piece of apparel by others. The Clients fly their colours, and it's quite a thing to see. As I said, they like a banquet meeting, and their normal banquet meetings look like the annual dinner banquet from the heyday of Peoria's Hansoms of John Clayton, so their "normal" is a nice evening for myself and the good Carter.

While we ate, they had their toasts -- based on the story of the evening, which was nice -- and we rolled through toasts to Percy Phelps by Alan Schweitzer, Annie Harrison by Ann Lewis, Dr. Watson by Shelly Gage, Mrs. Hudson by Regina Stinson (via Zoom) annnnd Joseph Harrison by Steve Doyle. If you thought that last one sounds like a dangerous combination, you would be right, as Steve came up with a clever defense of Percy Phelps's brother-in-law that haunted later discussions that evening.

The Clients have an interesting show and tell segment, which other scions have borrowed to some success, in which unique items of Sherlockian interest get explained and shown. I'd try to explain them here but probably fail to do them justice. Sherlock Holmes has inspired such an incredible variety of artifacts that it boggles the imagination sometimes.

A quiz on "Naval Treaty" had been put on the tables early on, and quizmistress Kira Settingsgaard provided the answers. Out of twenty-four possible point, I got fourteen, but a good share of the Clients seemed better prepared and did much better. The quiz was followed by a story discussion led by Mark Walters, going through several key points of the tale, and trying to discourage negative comments about Percy Phelps, the client and victim of the tale, which might have been inspired by a certain Joseph Harrison toast earlier. Personally, I came away from the evening with much less respect for Percy Phelps than I had begun with.

I mean, think about it, this guy was entrusted with a highly, highly, HIGHLY secret government treaty, loses it, then after a curiously convenient bout of "brain fever," thinks, "Oh, I'll write a boy I knew at school who is publishing stories in The Strand Magazine to get his famous friend to find the TOP SECRET document."  Sure, Percy. Sure.

The evening closed with Kelly Hodges, a newly minted Client and recent Irene Adler on the Kokomo stage, reading Vincent Starrett's poem 221B, which is the classic way to finish any Sherlockian evening. 

All in all, the Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis do a well organized, very nice meeting, and have for quite a long time. You don't have to wait for a special event to have a nice evening there. But as bad evenings, afternoons, mornings, or what have you are rare amongst all of the Sherlockian societies I've ever visited, so I'd encourage looking for convenient opportunities down the road from wherever you are. Eventually you have to drive home, but you'll get a lot to think about on the way and probably come away inspired for future Sherlockian adventures.

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Is Yours A Library or Lumber-Room?

 “I say now, as I said then, that a man should keep his little brain-attic stocked with all the furniture that he is likely to use, and the rest he can put away in the lumber-room of his library, where he can get it if he wants it."

-- Sherlock Holmes, "The Adventure of the Five Orange Pips"

Last week, I saw a comment on a social post, from one Sherlockian to another, suggesting that books should be shared and not hoarded. "Hoarded" seemed like a strong word for the collecting impulse that has run through Sherlockians like a virus since our early days, but I understood the point. Eventually one reaches an age when they start to wonder how their books will live on past their owner, which can cause one to wonder "Why DO I have all these books?"

When I was younger, non-Sherlockian, non-reader visitors would often ask, "Have you read all those books?" It seemed like such a silly question. Why would I own books that I hadn't read? Over time, however, as the Sherlockian collecting impulse wore away at me, I started to own a lot of books I hadn't read. Reference books, of course, which aren't meant to be read cover-to-cover. Biographies, which might have been meant to be read cover-to-cover, but often just serve as reference books after the fourth or fifth book on the same man's life. And those alternate copies of the same sixty stories -- old pirate editions, editions with unique illustrations, etc.

Enjoyable new novels of Sherlock Holmes, both pastiches and those featuring Holmes-based characters, remain on the shelves as reminders and tributes to the authors who wrote them. The dull, pedestrian works tend to get re-homed at one Sherlockian event or another. As the decades have passed, a lot of Sherlock Holmes books have left my library when they proved less than memorable, for reasons good OR bad. And at this point, even some quality works have left the shelves as the honest realization comes that I'm never going to refer to the particular subject at the heart of the book in my remaining years. I hate to say which, as I especially don't want to upset fans of a particular actor since my home went particular-actor-free a little while back. But that move also delighted one particular fan of that particular actor in the largess they received as the books left my house.

And that's the point that I think the "hoarding" comment was intended to make. When we're young we dream of shelves and shelves of books filling our house. But as lovely as a home library can be, it can also turn into a graveyard of books that won't see another reader until an estate sale. At some point, setting a few free to find new owners to love them is not a bad thing.

When Sherlock Holmes said that notable thing about brain-attics and lumber-room libraries, he was talking about internally held facts, but it also can apply to our external libraries. A person should keep all the books they are likely to use in the future, whether for reference or rereading. But there are also a good many that can be put away in the hands of other Sherlockians, where they can finally get to them if they want them.

There are personal libraries, organized, curated, loved. And then there are lumber rooms where books are just piled and stored as time goes by and we let it all get away from us. I've had both, so I'm not going to shame anyone for letting the Sherlockiana pile up. It happens. But eventually . . . eventually! . . . it's good to take an objective look at the books one owns and decide where their best home might be. Or not. You do you and enjoy whatever that winds up being.

Wednesday, October 21, 2026

The Deerstalker Lady

 In 2026, the age of everything everwhere all of the time via the internet, it is truly hard to wrap one's head around the Sherlockian experience of forty years ago in 1886. The level of hunger for things related to Sherlock Holmes, the barren Holmes and Watson landscape we spent our days in, the simple fact that if ANY book that starred Sherlock Holmes crossed your path you bought it . . . it was a very different time.

On the wall behind my computer screen is a little picture that always reminds me of those days, as it's not something that would probably seem a must-have to a 2026 Sherlockian.


It's simply a lady in hunting garb, with a rifle and a deerstalker cap.

In the 1980s, if a character was wearing a deerstalker, be it Snoopy, Garfield, a Cabbage Patch kid, etc., etc., etc., they were plainly imagining they were Sherlock Holmes and collectors grabbed up whatever form they appeared in. This deerstalker lady, however, was definitely not playing Sherlock Holmes carrying a rifle -- a form of weaponry Holmes never picks up in the original Canon. She's plainly just a woman going hunting.

But in the 1980s, a time when the Baker Street Irregulars did not invite women to their annual New York dinner, this image of a woman in a deerstalker felt like it held an added statement, and when I encountered it in the framing store where I had taken a particular item to get framed, it seemed a must-buy.

Will this simple print have any meaning down the line, when my Sherlockian collection eventually gets dispersed to the winds when I am gone? That will be for whoever's hands it falls into to decide -- we each give these objects meaning as we go through our lives. But for now, the deerstalker lady remains on my wall, reminding me of a time long ago when things were very different.

So, you go, deerstalker lady. Hope you bagged whatever you were hunting for.



Friday, October 9, 2026

In Defense of Will Ferrell's Sherlock Holmes

 Catching up on some television I missed this week, with a changing of the guard between seasons finished and seasons started, and found my way back to The Hawk on Netflix, a comedy about a has-been pro golfer intent on making a comeback. It starred Will Ferrell, playing a typical Will Ferrell character, and brought back to mind his Sherlock Holmes from the movie Holmes & Watson.

A typical Will Ferrell character is a prideful idiot, the sort who thinks he's the best at whatever he does, being it golf, basketball, TV anchoring, Eurovision Song Contest, you name it. And did Sherlock Holmes think he was the best at what he did?

Yes, he did. It's Canon. Score one point for Mr. Ferrell.

And somehow, yes, somehow, those prideful idiots succeed by the end of the movie. And did Sherlock Holmes succeed at the end of a case?

Well, mostly.

And a typical Will Ferrell character has enormous weaknesses. Bad habits, poor social graces . . . oh, wait, doesn't Sherlock Holmes have those same traits?

So why is it that a few Sherlockians so disdain a Will Ferrell Sherlock Holmes whilst celebrating Michael Caine's idiot Holmes in Without A Clue? Why do they decry Ferrell as an American miscasting mistake whilst accepting two movies from Robert Downey Jr., who doesn't even hit the Holmes height requirement like Will Ferrell.

Well, I could say some fans might take their fandom a little too seriously to have some fun with Holmes & Watson. Or I could say some folks have that Saturday Night Live issue, where they bonded with one season's cast in their childhood and won't accept the comic stylings of any other. Or, I could just say, well, it's okay if they don't get it, because sometimes, life just takes you on a sub-optimal path. But all of those would be ad hominum arguments, the last resort of the desperate debater that we see so often in the modern political arenas. And Holmes & Watson doesn't need that. It's got John C. Reilly. It's got Kelly Macdonald. Rebecca Hall. Hugh Laurie. Ralph Fiennes. Lauren Lapkus. Steve Coogan. Rob Brydon. And Queen freakin' Victoria, who they say was played by someone called Pam Ferris, but that sure looked like Queen Victoria to me. That's a cast!

The theme song to Netflix's The Hawk is lyrically brief: "They call him the Hawk. He's a golfer. The greatest golfer in the world."

Can you hear an echo of Sherlock Holmes in those words? I can. But maybe that's because I relate to those characters the same way I've always related to Sherlock Holmes. Prideful, socially inept, but somehow sure it's all going to work out in the end. And maybe just self-aware enough to connect to just being an idiot sometimes. And like the much lauded The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes, which shares a few things with Holmes & Watson, maybe that's what makes it a favorite of mine.

Your mileage may vary, so enjoy whatever movie you're driving for whatever your favorites are. But Holmes & Watson is not a movie to be so easily dismissed.


Saturday, September 26, 2026

Demolishing the Yew Alley

 It's not often that one does Sherlockian yardwork.

But today, after mowing the lawn I decided that a certain corner of the lawn, which had been host to some weeds, needed to be more mower friendly, and generally cleaned up for the next owners to come a few years down the road. Paving stones, border bricks, a pedestal with a sundial, all butting up to a corner of an eight foot wooden fence.

That wooden fence wasn't always there. When we moved into our home, nearly three decades ago, our entire backyard was bordered by a picket fence, meant for keeping little kids and small dogs from running off. It was old and a bit rickety, and when a new neighbor to the north moved in and wanted a more secure metal fence for their dog, we said "Sure, you can replace the fence on your side!" Eventually the same question came from our backyard neighbor for their larger dogs, and a larger fence went in. And finally, the same for our neighbor to the south. "Good fences make good neighbors," as the saying goes.

Yet before all that took place, when we first moved in, a path had been build between our backyard and the house diagonally across from the southwest corner said yard. And that house was owned by my old Sherlockian friend, Bob Burr, who had spent the previous six months of his retired life seeing houses for sale on his morning walks and suggesting we move into his neighborhood. And after several rounds of "No, we want a TWO car garage!" and the like, he did find us one that met all our requirements, catty-cornered to his own property.

I'm not sure who decided their house was Baskerville Hall in the ensuing months, but we got permission from the other neighbors to make a little walk between our yards which we called "the Yew Alley" after the site in The Hound of the Baskervilles. Newsletter columns, proofs of journals, new books picked up for my friend -- all those things and more started using that route for delivery. And since I could look down from an upstairs window to see when Bob was out on his back patio for his evening cocktail, just delivering any news or gossip in person became an easy thing as well via the Yew Alley.

When Bob passed away in 2013, the passage was closed off, yet the landscaping I'd put in that corner remained. The sundial he had so carefully calibrated when I went to put it in. The short path of stones that now went nowhere. And after thirteen years of upkeep worthy of a drunken Hudson of a gardener, the corner slowly became a shadow of its former self, and the time for clean-up had come.

So, raising a glass to the morning's efforts, and that happy past this chore came from, I'm bidding adieu to the last of the Yew Alley today. Glad to have had it while we did.

Monday, September 21, 2026

The 80th Anniversary Dinner of the Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis

Let us talk for a moment about the life of the extroverted introvert.

We didn't start as social creatures. And we might never master the social graces of a true extrovert. We learn to summon confidence. We learn to be comfortable doing things like speaking publicly. We can host sometimes, lead sometimes (always comfortable having a little control), and sometimes even appear the extrovert. But inside, well, there still can live that shy, awkward version of ourselves who still remembers all the times we were the puzzle piece that just seemed to be from a different puzzle.

I have to start there, because that was where I started my weekend. But last month, I had decided that I wanted to attend the 80th Anniversary Dinner of the Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis. I'd be driving down by myself, sure, but if one was spending the night, one typically meets people at the hotel . . . except this time, I apparently picked the wrong choice of the two. There were no Sherlockians to be seen in any of my trips through the lobby in the two hours before the dinner.

So I dressed, got in the car, set the navigation, and headed to dinner.

One of the final turns came up, and I suddenly found myself at a gate with a guardhouse. Never been to a country club with a guard at the gate. I mentioned the Illustrious Clients and Sherlock Holmes, and he opened the gate without a word, and I drove quite a few blocks through a very nice community, eventually getting to a nice country clubhouse. I saw two people I didn't know dressed very well heading in, and my socially anxiety was just peaking nicely. On another night, having not driven so far, I might have turned tail and spent my evening elsewhere. (It hasn't happened more than twice in decades, but it has happened.)

Inside, there was a sign pointing up a big staircase, so up I went. And there was a crowd filling the floor above the stairs. I stepped off that staircase and the minute my feet hit the second floor, everything changed. 

I got a big hug. Someone brought my name badge. The furthest travelled of the evening's speakers came over to say "hi." One of my favorite distant friends asked if we could sit together. Sherlockians happened.

This is the magic of Sherlock Holmes.

The character tends to attract those of who relate to that fine example of eccentricity in full functional flower, a lonely figure whose great friend Watson is always there. Once we find other Sherlockians and the camaraderie of similar enjoyments -- and often similar anxieties -- we find a home, and more than that, a battery we can plug ourselves into.

As I still didn't have a one hundred percent charge in my social battery at that point, I didn't mingle much during cocktail hour, and have to apologize to anyone I missed saying "hi" to, as I picked a seat in the furthest corner of the room. And I also have to thank everyone that did come by to say hello, and even though I'm not naming a lot of names here, I was especially pleased to get to meet Alex Katz, who came by to pass along his father's greetings. But let's talk about point of this whole essay, the Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis.


Firstly, they set a nice table. After eighty years, one might expect that.

Secondly, their local members are good company, no matter who sits at your table. I used to get down to Indianapolis a lot more often than recent years, and that was always the case. I actually think I got my first bout of Covid from a dinner they had packed into a restaurant down in Bloomington after that pandemic was supposedly done, but I had my shots and it was a mild case, so no regrets! Good company!

(Note: The other side of the table did get filled.)


The Clients have always been lucky with their leadership, and Shelly Gage, the current head of the Clients, is no exception. She gave some opening remarks and started sending tables to the excellent buffet that the country club provided. I want to commend the Clients on letting us get our food before the toasts started. One can never fully enjoy a toast if it feels like it's standing between you and dinner, especially those five minute essays that some events mistake for toasts.

The toasts this time were especially moving, as besides Sherlock Holmes (of course), they toasted key figures in the Clients' history who were no longer with us. I had known most of them, and had many a fond memory to associate with each of them. So many had even been in my house once upon a time, because the Clients tend to get around. 

That was going to be a tough act to follow, but the person who followed it has always been the figurehead of the Illustrious Clients to me, even when he wasn't leading the group. One of my numerous faux pas in my Sherlockian life was presenting some token to the club at a meeting and giving it to Steve Doyle instead of Don Curtis, just because Steve has always been a standout Sherlockian. From his tales of ER videography to serving jugs of Petri wine, Steve tends to be distinctly memorable, and for this occasion he once more proved the point, with a talk that started with the thesis "Indianapolis is the Sherlockian capital of the world."  


In the hands of anyone else, especially in his current role as leader of the freakin' B.S.I., such a premise might come off as sheer pomposity. But it's Steve. He knows the key that Sherlockiana is best played in for a talk, a little fun, a little smart, and just a tad nutty. Of course, Indianapolis is the Sherlockian capital of the world, and now we all get the fun of disproving that thesis in the months and years to come. (Personally, I'm hoping Wisconsin makes a go of it!) I loved his talk.

We got a break for dessert and the auction of a one-of-a-kind poster celebrating the Clients' history, which many of us signed. I found Steve at one point and got him to autograph my copy of Jerry Williamson's horror novel The Tulpa, for reasons you might have seen in my review ot it. Then we got another great talk, the evening's keynote.

Les Klinger was in fine form as keynote, taking us through his personal Sherlockian journey, of science fiction authors and annotateds, of his love of Baring-Gould that so many of us can relate to, his ties to the Clients and how Indiana's Sherlockians helped get him to where he is. (And we got to hear of an updated annotated to come, which is kind of huge!) 

After Les came a recognition of the membership, with that thing where all the members stand and then sit down as the generations of membership go down the years. I will admit that I did take that moment to slip out for a needed restroom break, also somewhat embarrassed in the fact I'd forgotten to pay dues about ten years ago and had let my membership lapse. (Still have the certificate on my wall, though, and I did make sure some dues got paid on my way out.) A split-the-pot drawing, and the traditional reading of 221B, and the evening was over, at which point I headed back to my hotel ten miles away that was bustling with non-Sherlockians.

But here's the thing. I had a wonderful evening, despite being at a very low social ebb. I came away with that deep validation one gets with a good Sherlockian experience, where you know in your very bones that this hobby you've spent so much time and energy on was exactly the hobby that you needed in your life. Thanks to the Clients, thanks to the folks at my table, and apologies to everyone whom I didn't get a moment with or missed completely, as you still added your energy to the evening. 

I will have to get down to Indy again soon. The Sherlockian capital of the world is wherever you are when Sherlockians happen, and this weekend I got to be there.



Saturday, September 12, 2026

The Rise of the AI Sherlockian

 Perhaps I just stayed up too late last night and I'm cranky this morning. But then again, no.

When the first thing you see on the internet for your morning look-see is an AI generated ad for what is surely an AI-assisted book by someone who has already published an AI-assisted book THAT YOU BOUGHT. You tend to go -- and excuse the language, but here it is well deserved -- "Well, fuck that guy."

We all know driven Sherlockians. Those who love Sherlock Holmes so much that they just can't stop the Sherlocking. Once upon a time, that meant someone who read the Canon and read the Canon and read the Canon, taking copious notes, developing a specialty for a time,  then moving to another area of Sherlockian interest or just remaining the expert in that field. That was every Sherlockian of a certain level, once upon a time.

But it's 2026 and the devil runs on servers now. It's in our searches, in our emails, listening in on meetings, actually moderating meetings, working with doctors, making movies, acting in movies . . . well, I could go on all day.

And that devil LOVES a driven fan-boy. Well, all the devils love a driven fan-boy, because we're easy to tempt into bad things since the bait is pretty obvious.

It's too easy to go "just this once." 

Last fall, I was looking for a December activity for the John H. Watson Society and went "just this once" to see if Google's AI could produce a reader's theater adaptation of "Blue Carbuncle." And it did. And I was open about it, immediately AFTER I had folks read it, which made the actors feel a bit tainted, like they'd just found out their date was a prostitute. A bland and boring prostitute, too. 

Because here's the thing. When AI is your co-author, it's not your work. You can claim "Oh, I had the idea!" but your work is going to look the same as everyone else that used your co-author, the same way we all know that not-quite-painted art of that certain style that AI uses. And chances are, a hundred Sherlockians have had that same idea that you had, because there are only sixty stories and thousands of us, so anyone else could have done that same thing. Except that the real champion on that topic did the actual work and actually wrote the book using their actual words in their own actual voice.

Everybody's got ideas. Everyone. Even the AI has ideas. 

But if you're not going to take the time to actually do the work, why should I waste my own precious time on your non-work? If it takes me longer to read something than it took you to write it, that's just sad. I'm sorry you didn't learn the skills needed to do the thing. The problem is that we've just gone from the information age into the slop age, and we don't need you to create slop. The AI can and will do it without you. Maybe we'll invite it to the BSI dinner for being such a great Sherlockian.

Learn a skill. Check your sources. Be an actual human.

End of rant.

Wednesday, September 9, 2026

Just living in Doyle, Indiana with a tulpa . . .

 In honor of the 80th anniversary of the Illustrious Clients of Indianapolis, I decided this month to read a novel by their founder, J.N. Williamson, author of a whole bunch of horror novels. As the founder of our local Peoria scion was also a genre author (Philip José Farmer), we have a little sort of kinship to our neighbors down I-74, and as I'd heard a particular novel of Williamson's, The Tulpa, had Sherlockian bits in it, I grabbed the last copy Amazon had to offer.

It was an old used copy, with a duct-taped corner and pricing on the inside cover that was stamped "3 FOR $100" and with a newer sticker opposite that said "15¢," I knew that I was very late to the party, having paid $17.59 for the thing. But it arrived four days sooner than predicted, an I was going to have plenty of time to get it read before the Clients' anniversary dinner.

(WARNING! THERE WILL BE SPOILERS AHEAD!)


Diving right in, the book starts with a Rod Serling-like prologue before a first chapter about at old man at his wife's funeral who has a senile-seeming outburst that turns out to be prophetic. Nothing Sherlockian there, but then we come to Chapter 2 and the old man's son-in-law, a sportswriter named Steve Neal who lives in Doyle, Indiana. Seeing "Steve" and "Doyle" in such close proximity makes you wonder if Williamson might not have been a bit prophetic himself, but such thoughts are pushed aside as one reads this:

"Doyle, Indiana had been founded about a quarter of a century ago by a successful and wealthy favorite Hoosier son, who belonged to the Baker Street Irregulars, that group of tongue-in-cheek devotees of Sherlock Holmes. Despite the fact that the Irregulars claimed that Dr. John H. Watson, Holmes's loyal "biographer," was really the author and simply reporting the facts, Jay Finley Smith had named the town after the late Sir Arthur Conan Doyle."

Somehow this 25-year-old town has a bus station named "Charing Cross Station," a small hospital called "St. Bart's," a grocery store named "Covent Garden Market," fifteen Canonical streets, and an invitation only bar called "the Carlton Club," among other references. I was good when that all started with a life-sized statue of Conan Doyle in a town called Doyle, but at some point, you're just going "How rich and powerful was Jay Finley Smith?" and trying to calculate how one finances, builds, and then populates that whole situation in under 25 years. (I left out the Canonically named theater, jail, and police station the guy built, too.)

And things immediately get worse.

There's a BSI scion society called "the Master's Clients" that was founded by a fifteen-year-old who became "a Nobel prize winning author" who "thought the current group, for the most part, was composed of stuffed shirts who used the democratic sweep of Sherlockiana for social contacts."

Bravo, Mr. Williamson! This cranky aging Sherlockian salutes your full public display of cranky aging Sherlockian-ness! 

Sportwriter Steve from Doyle drives a car brand called Granada, which for a book published in 1980, is again, pretty psychic. Steve wants his rapidly failing father-in-law to come live with his family, though his wife Ellen isn't too thrilled about it. They move the old man in, and it's another thirty pages and a brief sex scene before we get another Sherlock Holmes reference: "Even more than Sherlock Holmes, his passionate avocation was the study of the unexplained, the unknown, wherever he might encounter it."

J.N. Williamson, to his credit, is a pretty readable writer. As the story goes on, delving into the old man's psychic predictions in a 1980 "ESP, telekinesis, UFOs" kind of way, I really did find it readable enough to plow through in a couple nights. Ah, for the good old days of gatekeeping editors at publishing houses! (Yeah, I said it. Have you read some of the stuff that sees print?) But back to the Sherlockian notes, as on page 117, I get:

"A mile away, William W. MacDonald, the bank vice president, patiently dusted his prized collection of Sherlockiana and then spoke with a fellow Holmes devotee on the phone, discussing an upcoming meeting of the Master's Clients."

And that's all that is said about that. It's part of a kind of a verbal camera pan across Doyle, Indiana.

Thirty pages later, a full 147 pages in, we finally get the titular tulpa. If you want to read up on tulpas on Wikipedia, I'll wait. They're not nearly as exciting as a whole Sherlockian-built town, which we immediately get back to as the next chapter starts. That crazy rich Irregular also had a tobbacco shop named "Bradley's" put in, a "Lomax London Library," a Northumberland Hotel, and a St. Paul's church. 

We then get to meet William W. McDonald, bank vice president and second-term president of the Master's Clients scion society. "He'd wandered into the society on the basis of twenty percent interest in the subject, eighty percent interest awareness of the opportunity to advance himself." In a Sherlock Holmes town like Doyle, Indiana, hell yes, you want to belong to that local scion society! McDonald is described as a hypocrite who hates the sort of riff-raff a Sherlock Holmes society attracts, being very in favor of limiting the membership. (Insert me making an angry cat sound and making claw hands here -- because J. N. Williamson is being very catty about someone, and I'd love to know whom, because gatekeeper Sherlockians didn't just exist in fiction in 1980!)

The annual meeting of the Master's Clients of Doyle, Indiana is coming up, and "Vincent Christopher Smith was flying in from the New York parent society, the money-loaded Baker Street Irregulars." (More money-loaded than the guy who built this whole Sherlockian town?) Smith can somehow nominate William McDonald for a third term as president of his local scion, over "Teddy Gerald, an idiosyncratic and overweight writer who fancied himself the soul of the Clients." (Dear me, Mr. Williamson, dear me!) Of course, McDonald puts on a deerstalker to think about all of this while he smokes a cigarette from Bradley's, but takes it off when our hero, Steve the sportswriter shows up to tell him that the psychic old man has predicted a bank robbery at McDonald's very bank.

McDonald pretty much blows the warning off, goes back to thinking about who will give the toasts to Irene Adler and Mrs. Hudson at his society banquet, puts his deerstalker back on and goes, "Deeper and deeper, Watson, deeper and deeper." (Which demonstrates what a fraud of a Sherlockian he must be if that's the closest thing to a line from the Canon he can imagine! Subtle, Mr. Williamson! Subtle!)

The bank robbery happens, and something about it makes the tulpa mad at McDonald, who is about to have his Master's Clients banquet at the Bagatelle Club. (Yes, that rich BSI built one of those in Doyle, Indiana, too!) The banquet at that fanciest of clubs costs $25, which McDonald thinks will keep the Sherlockian riff-raff from attending. (That's $101.31 in today's money, according to Google.) And Vincent Smith comes to the banquet. Who is Vincent Smith?

"A founder of the national Baker Street Irregulars but originally a native of Chicago, Vincent Smith was both a novelist and a book critic whose severest reproach tended to be a comment that the writer 'might try a jot harder, next time."

Smith wore a deerstalker, like a lot of the people attending the banquet -- a banquet with six tables, so .... something like forty-eight attendees? There's also a dais, so lets say fifty-some. Vincent Smith toasts with a cup of coffee, saying "To the best and wisest man I have ever known," which the members of the Master's Clients all follow with "To Sherlock Holmes!" The Master's Class plainly isn't a society where five minute essays are called toasts, as the next guy (McDonald's rival, Teddy Gerard) just goes "To the woman!" and the members go "To Irene Adler!" Why?

Because according to the author, "Meetings of the Irregulars and their diverse scion societies were sometimes known, on a good wet night, to toast half the characters in the the 'Sacred Writings' before getting down to the slightly alcoholic proceedings." (Word on the street is that there are like 800 characters in the Canon. "Slightly alcoholic?") The Master's Clients limit themselves to just five toasts, though, and banker McDonald gets up to read his paper on Moriarty actually being Satan. He's expecting Indiana University professor Ruthoffer to come in dressed as Moriarty and have some words with him as a dramatic surprise, but it isn't Ruthoffer/Moriarty that busts into the banquet . . .

It's the tulpa.

Chicago's own Vincent Smith knows an otherworldly critter when he sees it and books out of there, but William W. McDonald remembers the old man's psychic warning from earlier being like a quote from The Valley of Fear, and that The Valley of Fear had a police inspector with a name like his . . . and while McDonald is thinking all that instead of running for his life, the tulpa lifts McDonald up with psychic energy and . . .

[CONTENT WARNING: A guy is about to have his head removed from his body in a violent manner.]

Oh . . . well, I guess the cat is out of the bag on that. One of the members thought he was watching a Reichenbach Falls reenactment until that point. Some Sherlockians try to fight the tulpa, and really bad things happen to them. Picture the movie Carrie ending with a Sherlockian banquet. Yeah.

Sportwriter Steve hears about the tragedy, almost immediately has unsatisfying sex with his wife, then sets about trying to solve the mystery of the tulpa. He learns what he can about the Master's Clients bloodbath from an old nudist Sherlockian who was there, then calls Chicago's own Vincent Smith, who tells him, "If you're going after the monster, Neal, let me commend to your attention a few words from The Hound of the Baskervilles, possibly the finest Sherlock Holmes book. First, 'The devil's agents may be of flesh and blood, may they not?' And these words of Mr. Holmes himself: 'It's dead, whatever it is!'"

Plainly, asking a Chicago Sherlockian for monster-hunting advice is not your best course in a tulpa situation. A movie theater screen and a policeman both take serious damage before sportswriter Steve's psychic father-in-law, whose stroke-brain created the psychic Frankenstein, decides to die and the tulpa disappears. No more Sherlockians are harmed, and the book ends without any more tours of Doyle, Indiana and its Sherlockian businesses.

J.N. Williamson's The Tulpa is a pretty readable book, as I've said, but definitely of its time. It's that kind of cheap paperback novel that is disappearing today, and it will be harder and harder to find a copy as the decades pass. The guy was definitely cranky about a lot of Sherlockian goings-on in the late 1970s, and I'm looking forward to going to the Master's Clients . . . excuse me . . . the Illustrious Clients' 80th Anniversary celebration to hear more about Williamson and the history of the club he founded as a teen.

I just hope no one loses their head at that banquet.


Monday, September 7, 2026

Ronald Howard's Final Problem

 Sometimes, even a complete fool can point you to facts you never saw where there . . .

I don't know if you listen to a podcast called Sherlock Holmes Is Real, being the sort of Sherlockian with a level of intelligence that are the typical readers of this blog, but their latest episode "The Footage of the Tyrant's Daughter," called my attention to something I had never realized before. And maybe you hadn't noticed it either.

I was never a tremendous fan of the Ronald Howard TV series, Sherlock Holmes, that ran from October 16, 1954 to October 17, 1955, with thirty-nine half-hour episodes. The show was as much comedy as drama, with Watson and Lestrade played for laughs, as well as a lot of Holmes's clients. Like all shows of the time, there wasn't much continuity, and Sherlock Holmes featured more original scripts than adaptations and a whole lot of pretending France was England.

The final episode The Case of the Tyrant's Daughter was the focus of the Sherlock Holmes Is Real "experts" this week, and I think there was something that they missed completely as they became distracted by the show's end credits and some lower case letters there. And that was that they were dealing with the final time that viewers saw Ronald Howard's version of Sherlock Holmes.

One might even say it was that Holmes's "Final Problem."

For the very last time TV audiences saw that Sherlock Holmes, he was sitting looking sick to his stomach after accidentally drinking tea mixed with a rare Egyptian poison.


He has poisoned himself, and the last thing we see on screen, the last image from the whole TV run of the show is Watson's panic.

Was this season cliffhanger, which was never resolved, this Sherlock's "Final Problem?" Was "The Case of the Tyrant's Daughter" secretly the "Dying Detective," only this time he really dies?

Perhaps the tone of the show was just wacky enough that audiences took Holmes's self-poisoning as just another comic riff to get Watson over-excited, but Holmes doesn't seem to be faking internal issues from the poison. There's not Professor Moriarty in this TV series. No arch-villain other than Sherlock Holmes himself, who seems to have done himself in. With no second season to rectify matters, Sherlock Holmes leaves us like this year's CBS Watson -- with the thought that the main character may now just be dead, and no official assurance that things were otherwise.

I hope the folks on the Sherlock Holmes Is Real podcast take up this issue, though I shudder to think what nonsense they'll be coming up with to pile on it. But I do have to thank them for pointing out Sherlock Holmes's self-poisoning end to that series, which I certainly hadn't noticed before.



Saturday, August 29, 2026

Sherlockian Writings: Our Limits

 I stumbled across an old letter from 2010 in some cleaning this morning, in which a Sherlockian friend was writing to me about some recent doings and what they enjoyed about it all. I'm going to keep them anonymous, but something written fit so well into some other current thoughts I've had that I have to quote them here, from their thoughts sixteen years ago:

"It seems that we drift more and more into BSI history, tributes to Sherlockians, bibliographic inventorying, collection analysis, library overviews, etc. All of that is fine and interesting, but I perceive that there is less and less of the old-fashioned Sherlockian 'scholarship' and the whimsical fun that makes it all worthwhile."

The fine Sherlockian scholar who wrote those words was quite right about that drift . . . the last few Sherlockian books I've purchased fall completely into those "drift" categories. I've even written a Sherlockian history book myself, as has my friend who wrote those words. And there are very good reasons for that . . . if you're a writer and you love writing about Sherlock Holmes and all the fruit falling from that great tree, and you keep writing, you tend to wind up in places you never thought you'd go. Because eventually, walking around the same part of that orchard gets so familiar that you want to branch out.

Just before discovering the letter I mentioned, I sent the draft of another issue of Sherlockian Chronology Timelines off to associate editor Rob Nunn for his pre-publication scrutiny. Now in our sixth year of filling a mostly-monthly newsletter with chronology articles, I'm starting to wonder if we've hit the outer limits of that topic. It the opening editorial, I even started to cross a line that most seem hesitant to cross.

The "old-fashioned Sherlockian 'scholarship' and whimsical fun" in the quote above is that great old game of working from the premise that Watson's records of Sherlock Holmes are real historical works. Sherlockian chronology has its feet firmly planted in that chosen delusion. But if we start to use our own historical calendar, and the notion that Watson was publishing his stories in the Strand Magazine, with the assistance of a literary agent named Conan Doyle, suddenly Conan Doyle's personal history comes into play. 

Is that out of bounds in playing the game? Off limits? Is pairing Watson and Doyle together, even without changing facts in Doyle's life, disrespectful to the latter author? Or to Watson himself, in suggesting that Conan Doyle had to rewrite so much of Watson's words that he got the writing credit?

Those rare listeners to the Watsonian Weekly podcast know that an occasional feature of the podcast over the years has been "The Literary Agent's Ten Percent" where Conan Doyle's history and Watson's history intertwine, so they know I'm definite not afraid to go there. Not many do, though, choosing to stay either on the "fact" side of writing or the "fancy" side of writing. 

The limits in our Sherlockian hobby are completely based on your personal choices. A specific editor or publisher might have different limits, but in a hobby where so many have just written and privately published for their friends from day one, you can definitely do what you want to do. And your own version of "the fun that makes it all worthwhile" is yours to choose as well.

Just try to clean up after yourself, which is what I have to get back to doing!

Saturday, August 22, 2026

Cleaning Up A Sherlockian Life Spent In Paper

 After having a few Sherlockian friends at the house a while back, I have a very tidy Sherlock Holmes room. Call it a library, call it a study, call it a personal archive, it's the room where this little hobby took up residence from the day we moved into this house. And it took a bit of cleaning to prep for guests.

Cleaning, at this point in our house, typically involves moving things from the location being made to look presentable to a location whose door will be closed to visitors, or basement storage. Which means, when the guests have left, one is left with a room that has a lot of odd things in it, things that don't really fit in with the rest but, for whatever reason, seem like they can't be thrown away or donated to some charity. And so much of those things, at this point, are paper.

Not books. Books fit on shelves. Books are easy.

Letters. Newsletters. Pamphlets. Flyers. Monographs. Quizzes. Presentations that were handed out on paper before or after they were spoken. And every bit of it, about Sherlock Holmes.

The literal paper trail of a life as a Sherlock Holmes fan well spent. History, one might say.

But does all history need to be preserved? When a guy named Tom Simpson wrote a quiz on "The Lion's Mane" for the March 1979 meeting of a Peoria, Illinois scion society and another person who didn't put their name on the quiz paper scored a 72 out of 80 questions . . . does that need to be placed in a library archive and preserved for all eternity? Or even scanned and kept somewhere digitally?

So much of the joy of Sherlockiana is the doing. Concocting a quiz on "The Lion's Mane" is much more fun than taking a quiz on "The Lion's Mane," and future Sherlockians should have that joy. If there was ever only one quiz on "The Lion's Mane" that we kept passing around, in all Sherlockian venues, whenever the tale came up, what a dull place the world would be!

Because here's the hard question about culture, history, and humans that becomes more pertinent in the later years of one's life: Does everything need to be preserved? Sometimes we aren't losing a thing -- we're gaining the opportunity for some future person to do a thing. Because doing that thing is fun. And maybe, without hurting anyone's feelings here, that earlier version of a thing might not have been the best attempt at it. That's life. Each generation replaces the last and takes up a mantle that has been patched, re-sewn, darned, replaced in places, and wears it anew.

 So what do we do with all of the by-products of a Sherlockian life? How much is just waste that needs to be disposed of? How much should be handed off to the next generation?

Tough questions, but ones that must be dealt with.

Sunday, August 16, 2026

Doctor Watson's Xanadu

 Long have Sherlockians puzzled and conjectured over Watson's marital situation, and the wife who is there, but not there, proposed to as "Mary Morstan" and never spoken of by name again. Such mysteries live on for years, decades even, in our minds . . . until some little thing, just one little innocent thing, triggers the answers that were there all along.

I have Max Magee to thank for this. During a recent film festival game of collecting four Sherlock Holmes movies to create a Sherlockian film festival, Max decided to make his film fest be:

1. Hound of the Baskervilles
2. Sherlock Gnomes
3. Xanadu
4. Heaven's Gate

The last two may seem plainly due to Max's roller skating fetish and his desire to make "Prince's Skating Club" from "The Adventure of the Red Circle" of Canonical importance. However the movie Heaven's Gate takes place in 1890, and features Ellen Watson, a Wyoming bordello manager who very well have been a cousin of Doctor Watson's should one remember certain authoritative treatises in The Baker Street Journal on Watson's American origins. But Xanadu, a 1980 musical filled with the fashion and music of the day?

Xanadu is the tale of a pretty blonde woman that skates into a man's life and inspires him to follow his creative dreams. And, it turns out she's a full on daughter-of-Zeus muse, who appears on Earth to with the sole purpose of doing that inspiration, something she's done throughout time.

So let's stop for a moment and think. John H. Watson met Sherlock Holmes in 1881, and worked with him for six years before he thought of writing and publishing his adventures with Holmes. No, that didn't happen until 1887. And what else happened to John Watson in 1887, according to so many notable Sherlockian chronologists?

He met a pretty blonde woman, whom even inspired Holmes as someone "who might have been most useful in such work as we have been doing."

There is a vision in the movie Xanadu of the muse Kira, in another era inspiring another artist four decades before. It makes it very easy to imagine yet another scene missing from the movie of Olivia Newton John in 1887, showing up in Baker Street with some pearls and a fever-dream of a case for Holmes and Watson. A pygmy with poison darts, a one-legged escaped prisoner, a treasure lost in a maritime (well, river maritime) battle . . . why wouldn't anyone start thinking of writing such things down?

But muses do not stay around forever, being magical creatures with a job to do. And after Watson seems to lose his writing spark in the mid 1890s, what is it that brings him back to taking pen in hand? 

"The good Watson had at that time deserted me for a wife, the only selfish action which I can recall in our association. I was alone."

Technically, one always has to wonder over those words "only selfish action," as Watson seems to have deserted Holmes for a wife twice. With a long gap in between which makes it hard to see as a gap in a single marriage to a normal woman in that era. But a muse, who would return to Mount Olympus and then one day return to inspire Watson again when the need seemed dire?

Mary Morstan . . . perhaps not the Terpsichore of Xanadu, but her sister who appears in the opening muse dance, Melpomene, whose name also features the double "M"s . . . the muse of tragedy. For isn't so much of Watson's work inspired tragedy? Murder, loss, love gone wrong?

Sherlockian chronologists have long watched Max Magee try to inspire Sherlockians to mix Back to the Future into the Sherlockian mythos somehow. Perhaps this time, however, he has hit upon the real vein of gold and the movie Xanadu finds ties to the Watson works that really do work . . .


Wednesday, August 5, 2026

Your Top Five Sherlock Holmes Movies

Before and after our weekly recording of The Watsonian Weekly podcast, Madeline Quinones, Heather Hinson and I always have some other Sherlockian gossip and chat that goes unrecorded. An occasionally there's some chat that might have been worth putting on the podcast. Tonight it just occurred to me to ask a simple question: "What are your top five Sherlock Holmes movies?"

Fifty years ago, there were nearly the smorgasbord of Sherlock Holmes movie choices we have today, and we've all had the pleasure of seeing the right movie at the right time in our lives, which might give a particular choice more meaning to us that to our friends. And there are generational favorites at this point, as well. The Great Mouse Detective would definitely be on the list of one Sherlockian we know, while another would point to The Seven-Per-Cent Solution . . . and neither of those made it to any of our top five lists.

So, without further adieu, here are the top five Sherlock Holmes movies of the Watsonian Weekly podcast crew:

Heather's Top Five:

  • Young Sherlock Holmes
  • The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes
  • The Return of the World's Greatest Detective (Larry Hagman as Holmes)
  • Sherlock Holmes (Robert Downey Junior as Holmes)
  • Sherlock Holmes (and Dinosaurs)

Madeline's Top Five:

  • Game of Shadows
  • Without A Clue
  • Murder By Decree
  • Enola Holmes 2
  • Her imagined unreleased pro-shot of the Ken Ludwig Moriarty premiere.

Brad's Top Five:

  • The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes
  • Holmes & Watson
  • Sherlock Holmes in New York
  • Sherlock Holmes (Downey)
  • The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (Rathbone)

There you have it. Make of it what you will. And, you know, there is a comment section below this for your own top five, should you feel so inclined! (And our comment moderator will try to remember to check the approved comment list this week to make sure they get added ... at some point.)

Wednesday, July 29, 2026

Holmes in the Heartland 2026: Sherlock Haunts!

 This weekend, I left my laptop at home.

Being on the committee for a weekend conference requires a little more attention than my usual "time to tippy-tap on the laptop" reporting as it goes, and this one definitely did. St. Louis's "Holmes in the Heartland 2026: Sherlock Haunts!" definitely deserved all of one's attention this past weekend.

I was weary when I arrived, having entertained a handful of out of town guests in Peoria the night before, which coincided with our monthly Thursday night library discussion group. That meant missing the screening of The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes in a theater near the conference, as well as the Friday morning maneuvers of the 221st Southumberland Waffleers, but sometimes Sherlockiana demands sacrifice.

The Cheshire hotel in St. Louis is a charming place, one that seems like it's been there a long time, but that works well with the "ye olde British" ambiance. Each room is dedicated to some literary figure, and upon check-in you get a bookmark with the name of your room, in addition to the usual number card folder. Mine was "William Makepeace Thackeray," 

One lucky raffle winner, Elaine Litzenich, won a special VIP attendee package, which included staying in the hotel's Sherlock Holmes suite, a custom name badge and lanyard, a choice door prize, private vendor shopping, and extra attention from the conference staff . . . though she was very sweet about that last part and did not demand too much of our service.

At 4:00 P.M. on Friday, early registration started, quickly followed by a lavish cocktail hour with such hearty and well-done hors d'oeurves that few needed to go to dinner after. The conference mascot, Boolock Holmes apparated for the first time at the Haunted Happy Hour, silently handing our spooky trivia for the crowd to test their table-mates with. (Boolock not pictured . . . yet.)



There was a little "Fox and Hound" pub in the main hotel, where many retired after cocktail hour for more chatting, and a good many of us overflowed across the hall onto the outdoor patio, as St. Louis was having a perfectly climated evening for our Friday night. A bag of kettle corn was discovered and passed around, and, well, it was just nice. Sherlockians are pleasant folk to spend time with, which is the real draw for these events.

The next day, folks were eager and ready to storm the upstairs conference room and vendors tables when 8:30 AM rolled around. The program didn't start until 9:30, but that hour was put to good use, especially by those who needed a little more sleep after the night before. Rob Nunn finally took the podium welcoming one and all and introducing the first speaker, noted book columnist Michael Dirda, who spoke on his Sherlockian path through life. Minnesota's own Julie McKuras came next, investigating what it was that must've haunted Sherlock Holmes himself throughout his life. After that firm foundation of a program start there was a 30 minute break to encourage more shopping with the vendors. (Holmes in the Heartland is nothing if not kind to its vendors!) After some door prizes were raffled off to bring everyone back to attention, comics sage Johanna Draper Carlson presented "Zombies, Vampires, and Monsters in Sherlock Holmes Comics," which was a wonderful update and array of the many appearances of Holmes in such comics. And after Johanna . . . a tough act to follow . . . came . . .


If, for any reason, you find yourself on the program at the very last minute, a mere eleven days before a conference, let us all hope you also find yourself merely being straight man to one of your most talented friends whom you've talked into filling a gap in the programming. Sherlockian and puppeteer Mary O'Reilly had done videos of her all-animal Sherlockian society for our annual Montague Street Incorrigibles meetings (one of which I appear in, with all the acting talent of a "Half in the Bag" host), but had never made her animal friends work a live audience before. Since Mary had already volunteered to play Boolock Holmes at the Haunted Happy Hour, it seemed perfect that Boolock could appear again with the animals.

Baskerville the hound, Buncle the goose, the Lion's Mane jellyfish, and Lucinda the swamp adder all appeared, so I could try to get them to talk about Sherlock Holmes, even if they had definite other ideas and tried to sell me fake carbuncles or get human members for their club. It was commented on, more than once, that I kept holding the microphone in front of the puppets when they spoke, but what I was actually doing was holding it in front of the "silent" Boolock, since ventriloquism is something anyone can do with a sheet over their head, and we needed that little assist for the act. But even when the microphone wasn't close, most of the animal voices pierced the ether of the conference room and kept the audience happy (and distracted, since we were the last bit before lunch and people were getting hungry).

Lunch was as excellent as the appetizers the night before, and I wish I had discovered dipping the grilled turky-and-gruyere sandwich in the tomato bisque sooner, as, WOW, was that good. I also piled my plate with arugula lettuce salad, defying the parasite gods that have been spreading fear amongst the fresh veg community this summer. 

Perhaps the most risky part of the program came next, as the sultry tones of podcast king Scott Monty could have easily relaxed the audience into a nice nap, but his survey of Sherlock Holmes in popular culture held the audience (and maybe even tweaked some a bit with his mentions of AI), and I noticed no snoozers. St. Louis Sherlockian Randy Getz followed Scott with an audio tour through the music and composers that appear in the Sherlock Holmes Canon and re-introduced us to many familiar tunes we might have forgotten. (Chopin's "Death March" especially sticks out in my memory, haven't possibly never known that trope of a dirge was Chopin's.) 

One last break for shopping the vendors' tables and we came to our final two acts, Ira Matetsky showing off the poetic side of Conan Doyle (his reading of "The Old Huntsman" was especially memorable), and Bob Sharfman showing off the Sherlockianity of Bob Sharfman. (I dunno, somehow it's just that and it just works.)  

Rob Nunn concluded the day's program and dismissed us for an hour to dress for the cocktail hour and banquet. Some of us are common sluggards who just wear what we were wearing all day, which is something one has to consider as an option in St. Louis in July, but banquet time is always an opportunity for those who like to raise their game for the evening. The Cheshire treated us right once again in the food department, and Scott Monty again took the microphone following a meal. But this time, Scott was stirring up interest in several auction items to raise money for the Beacon Society, and did a fine job of doing just that.

The after-dinner entertainment proper was "A Dinner Conversation with Conan Doyle," but spiritualist Maximillian P. Magee was overcome with the spirit of Sherlock Holmes who pushed Doyle aside to play host to several other spirits appearing out of the ether. Mary Sutherland, Agatha the maid, the King of Bohemia, and others, most of whom looked somewhat like Ashley Polasek or Curtis Armstrong but sounded quite different. It was quite the experience and I was overcome for a short time when it was over, retiring to my hotel room until the vapors passed, then returned to the Chesire's lobby area just outside the Fox and Hounds pub, where many a Sherlockian hung out to chat for the rest of the night.

It makes me tired just to think of how tired I was by that point, but morning came eventually, with elevatoring down to the parking basement to load the car up, a bit more lobby socializing, and then a trip to the Missouri History Museum for a look at the 1904 World's Fair, with its almost-ties to the world of Sherlock Holmes.  Sundays at Sherlockian weekends are usually the day when you see people slip away, bit by bit, from the early morning Sunday until sometime Monday. The line at the "Taste of Amighetti's" museum cafe seemed like my time to exit, as it seemed a bit understaffed to deal with an influx of Sherlockians, so I was well out of St. Louis and up the road by the time I would have eaten. And that was a very good thing, because an hour or so after alighting back home in Peoria, I was out for a much needed nap.

Being a part of the group putting on a conference (the Parallel Case of St. Louis, which I'm kind of "the neighbor who drops in now and then" membership-wise), one tends to hear all of the little squeaks in the machinery of the event and see all of the dings in the paint-job, but when all is said and done, we can mark "Holmes in the Heartland 2026: Sherlock Haunts!" as one in the "wins" column for this year. Getting together with Sherlockian friends is the important part, and one to be enjoyed whenever we're lucky enough to find ourselves immersed in a weekend like this one.





Thursday, July 9, 2026

Sherlockiana, the Serious, the Silly, and the Self-Actualized

 “Earnest people are often people who habitually look on the serious side of things that have no serious side.”  — Van Wyck Brooks, literary critic

There are folks in our hobby of Sherlockiana that love a footnote. Maybe their high school English teacher was especially comely on the day term papers were explained and their youthful hormones gave the lesson a bump. I dunno. Me, I don't need them unless they're their to make fun of footnotes. One early article I had in The Baker Street Journal did so with completely fake footnotes in it, as the editor asked for footnotes. Because I'm here to play.

A lot of people are here to play too, but their game has more rules than mine. And then there are the people who aren't here to play, those who write about the real lives of the real people who've been touched by a Sherlock Holmes. They get a pass. But I still think they could do without footnotes. End notes are fine, unless you're Baring-Gould or Les Klinger annotating something we've all, hopefully read once already in its raw state.

The point I'm getting at here isn't that one way or the other is wrong. We're all earnest people, we enthusiasts of the Great Detective (a.k.a. "fans," but some of the earnest are so earnest they'd rather not choose that as their . . . you know, we might want to put "fan," "afficionado," "enthusiast," etc. on name badges like they do with pronouns, so people can get their chosen noun). Where was I? Oh, yes, earnest. We're all earnest, dedicated folk, even those of us who are earnestly silly.

How silly is Sherlock Holmes, all in all? A character from an old mystery story who became iconic for detectivery?

Well, he's not serious enough for the bottom tier of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs. He isn't food, water, or shelter serious. And he doesn't provide us safety, as in the next tier up. But them it gets a bit serious.

The middle tier of Maslow is the "Love and Belonging" tier. Sherlock Holmes gets us friendship, chosen family, and . . . for a few, I have heard, but not specifically, nor am I naming suspects . . . sex. But, sticking with friendship, that's kind of serious, kind of important. And something we should consider in our approach to Sherlock Holmes. Being a friend is more seriously a part of Sherlock Holmes than writing a pastiche or doing research, I think, unless you're doing those for a friend.

Level up from the friendship tier and you come to "self-esteem." A lot of us get self-esteem from our Sherlockian adventures, and if you try to tell me the desire for a BSI shilling isn't about self-esteem, I might wonder about you a bit. Sherlockiana has some friendly audiences for toast, presentations, writings, and ways to build up your self-esteem as you build your skills. I occasionally get asked to speak in non-Sherlockian venues, and any compliments I get on that ability are built on what this hobby gave me. So while not as serious as friendships, self-esteem can be a serious part of the hobby as well.

So, top of this perhaps arguable pyramid, self-actualization. I love the little graphic on Wikipedia because its top tier is crammed with "morality, creativity, spontaneity, problem solving, lack of prejudice, acceptance of facts." In other words, "Sherlock Holmes."

Am I being silly? Or self-actualized enough to see Sherlock Holmes for the top of our aspirational pyramid, which is the serious side of a silly fictional character? 

There are a lot of reasons we're in this lovely little Sherlockian hobby. The very silly ones. The very serious ones. And the Sherlock Holmes ones.

So I guess you can have your footnotes. (Especially you chronologists.)

Thursday, June 18, 2026

Can the Shaw seminar come back without Shaw?

 A year ago this past April, the Baker Street Irregulars hosted their Canonical Conclave of Scion Societies in Indianapolis, an event intended to inspire. A lot of the Sherlock Holmes societies represented came away with renewed energies, and personally, I came away with an idea. I shared it with a couple of people at that event, who were enthusiastic for it, but ideas are easy. Fleshing them out is the real trick. So let's talk about that idea.

From 1977 to 1993, that grand Sherlockian John Bennett Shaw hosted weekend conferences all over the country, wonderful things during a time when there was no internet to connect us, no Google search to bring Sherlockians together. Most of us knew what we knew, initially, from the Baring-Gould Annotated Sherlock Holmes and its section on the Baker Street Irregulars. Going to one of Shaw's university based weekends was like finding a supercharger for a Sherlock Holmes fans and plugging yourself into it.

The idea of putting together a new Shaw weekend was intriguing, especially to a couple of fellows who had been in Peoria in 1979, when Shaw's planned Bradley University workshop was cancelled only a month before. (And nobody told a very angry Jack Tracy, who arrived in town thinking it was still happening.) The fiftieth anniversary of that Peoria failure is coming up, to the day, on July 20th, 2029. Peoria's still a decent enough place, with a pretty good airport, and accomodations enough, so the idea of trying to make up for that failure. (The local scion had only been in existence for two years. The local university didn't really know the circles to publicize it in either. And me, I had barely been out of college three months and hadn't met any Sherlockians in Peoria yet.)

Great idea on paper, sure. But how do you have a John Bennett Shaw workshop without John Bennett Shaw? It's not like we have Shaw tribute bands playing his hits. And a full on themed symposium about the Santa Fe collector is more Norwegian Explorer turf at this point, as they've done it before. Truly recreating a John Bennett Shaw workshop isn't about talking about Shaw. It's doing what he would have done, and doing it for the year and the world you were doing it in, and not 1979.

So what did a basic Shaw outline look like?

Friday evening was Shaw's opening talk, "Sherlock Holmes, Then and Now," an overview of Holmes history and the fandom, complete with poetry, important quotes, and stories. After that introduction, we'd all watch They Might Be Giants. Remember that video was only coming about when those took place and the chance to see a modern movie that loved Sherlock Holmes that much was rare. A new version of a Shaw workshop might pick something more current, but still a joy for all.

There might be a slide show of Shaw's collection first thing the next morning, where you could just be amazed at all the things Sherlock Holmes has inspired. The great thing about this is that Shaw's collection still exists, and is even greater now. A similar presentation is possible.

And, oh, we were quiz people back then, and John Bennett Shaw loved to test us with one of his particularly devilish quizzes. A timed quiz on a particular story might follow the first presentation, with another, on a second story later in the weekend. There were some good prizes and young minds often took the wins. Do we like to take tests now, fifty years later? Are we so competitive? You tell me. I'll pass.

Other speakers would come next, depending upon the particular workshop, but the topics tried to cover the important bases: Conan Doyle, parody and pastiche, cocaine, Afghanistan, Dorothy Rowe Shaw's miniature Baker Street, writing a Sherlockian paper, London, and more. Rare short films and cartoons would be shown as well. Shaw would often wind things up after dinner with a talk about the B.S.I. and Sherlockian societies, with stories and sing-alongs.

Sunday morning there might be a final quiz, winners of the short fiction contest announced (prompts were given of Friday evening and short-short stories had to be turned in by 5 PM Saturday), with prizes for the winners. The program of talks and short films continues into Sunday afternoon. You got a full weekend's worth from John Bennett Shaw, more like 221B Con length than most Sherlockian weekends these days.

If you consider what John Bennett Shaw's roadshow brought to so many cities in that long-ago decade, it was basically a full Sherlockian experience, covering everything that was the hobby at that time. We didn't have fanfic back in the 1980s, but if we had there would have been a talk on that. There might have been some short anime films, or other non-American rarities. In 2029, the full Sherlockian experience will be fifty years larger than it was in 1979. Television shows, audio mediums, comics, and commercial pastiches have grown exponentially. Sherlockian journals and newsletters rose and fell. Could you even cover the Sherlockian world as thoroughly as Shaw did in a single weekend now?

We aren't nearly as starved for Sherlockian content as we were back then, and do we have a John Bennett Shaw? Like the old saying says, you can't go home again. But you can move forward with hopes for a new place that's pretty great. The Shaw model, that Johnny Appleseed way of displaying the best of the hobby he loved so much to inspire others, is still useful. All of our current weekend conferences and events are the descendents of those Shaw weekends, after all. The big difference with Shaw was that he didn't settle in a single town and repeat the weekend -- he kept spreading the word.

Something to think about. And by the by . . . weren't some of you other regions hoping to try the Canonical Conclave thing? "Just asking," as those most irritating of trolls say. But you don't see me committing to putting a Shaw weekend on just yet, so I won't push. But we're always curious about what the years ahead will bring, so let's keep our eyes on that horizon.